Why not just use AI as a coach?
The answer was clear, organised and encouraging. A month later, nothing had changed.
I keep meeting people in the middle of a job search who have done everything right.
The CV has been through an AI tool and it is excellent. Tight, clear, the right keywords for the role. The LinkedIn profile matches it line for line. The applications go out every week.
The replies do not come.
By the time we talk, they have usually asked the AI about that too. It suggested a stronger summary and a few more keywords.
What AI is good at
Plenty. I use it most days, and I wouldn't suggest fighting great tools.
AI is a very good thinking partner. Give your favourite LLM a messy page of notes and it will hand you back a structure. Ask for twenty ways to describe a project and you will get twenty, three of them useful. It will draft, tidy, summarise and automate the dull parts of your week. It can keep a list of what you said you would do this week and ask you about it on Friday.
If that were all a coach did, you should cancel the coach.
It answers the question you asked
Go back to that CV. The tool improved it because improving it was the request. It did the job well.
Nobody asked whether the CV was the problem.
In most of these searches it was not. The search was aimed too narrowly: one job title, one sector, the same kind of company they had just left. Or it was built on volume: more applications, each one more generic, and more silence. I call that the panic loop, and The Job Hunt Playbook has a chapter on getting out of it. A better CV sent to the wrong places is still going to the wrong places.
The CV is only one example I see often. The same thing happens with bigger questions. Ask whether you should go for the promotion and it will help you make the case for the promotion. Ask how to handle a difficult manager and it will give you a plan for the manager you described. AI takes the question as you framed it and gets to work.
That is a blind spot.
You cannot prompt your way out of a blind spot.
To ask about it, you would need to know it was there.
Researchers tested something close to this over the summer. They gave people questions an AI model tended to get wrong, and let them ask it for help. On their own, 44% of people said "I don't know". With the AI, 3% did. Accuracy fell from 27% to 9%. Confidence rose from 30% to 76%. The study is written up here.
People were wrong more often and far more certain. That was a film quiz.
Now picture the same effect on a decision about your job.
Why a better prompt does not fix it
The usual advice is to prompt better. Tell it to challenge you. Ask it to play devil's advocate.
Try it.
It will challenge the things you mention. You still wrote the brief, and the brief is your version of events: what you think the problem is, who you think is in the way, what you have already ruled out. It works inside that version, because that version is all it has.
AI also leans towards agreeing with you. Push back on its challenge once and it will often concede the point. A person who has listened to you describe the same situation for an hour is harder to talk round.
Friction creates commitment
Closing a browser tab costs nothing. Nobody knows you did it.
The same goes for the reminder. Think about how many notifications you swiped away today without reading them. A tool that nudges you about your goals joins that pile within a week.
An hour in the diary with another person is different. You have to turn up. You have to say out loud what you did since last time, and what you did not. That small cost is the point.
What a person hears
AI is very good with information. It can gather it, sort it and hand it back in good order.
Coaching is relational, not informational. A person can read how you are feeling as you talk: the role you describe flatly, the one that speeds you up, the question you answer a little too quickly. None of that is in the text you would have typed.
The people I described at the start did not need more information. Few people with a career decision in front of them do.
Use both
Keep the AI. Use it to prepare, to draft, to think out loud at eleven at night when nobody else is awake.
Take the other thing to a person. The question you keep rewording. The decision you have made three times and unmade twice. The search that looks right on paper and is not working. If the CV really is the problem, start here.
A coach costs more than a subscription, and that is fair to weigh. Weigh it against what one better-aimed move is worth to you over the next few years.
If you are choosing a coach, these five questions will help. If you would like to talk it through with me, a discovery call is where it starts.
Before any of that, ask someone who knows your work one question.
What am I not asking about?
It is the one question a prompt cannot answer for you.
Get the next one by email.
One email every Monday, before it goes anywhere else. Always free.