6. The First Number is not the Last Number

Many people sign the first offer they're given. Not because it's fair. Because they want the whole thing to be over.

That instinct can be the most expensive feeling in a layoff, because the first number is almost always a starting position.

Start by understanding your selection

Before you talk money, understand how you got here.

You're allowed to ask how the redundancy pool was defined and what criteria were used to select you. If the pool is not clear to you, or the scoring is vague and subjective, that's not a complaint, it's a fact that changes your negotiating position.

If selection touched anything tied to a protected characteristic, age, sex, disability, pregnancy, race, you're no longer in a redundancy conversation, you're in a discrimination one, which is far more serious for them.

What the settlement agreement actually does

The document they'll put in front of you does one main thing. In exchange for the money, you give up your right to bring claims against them. That's the trade. It's often entirely reasonable.

However, it means the moment you sign is the moment your leverage ends, so everything you want has to be in there before the pen moves.

In many places you're entitled to take independent legal advice first, and the employer often contributes to the cost.

Use that.

What's actually on the table

People think the only number is the payment. It's the most visible lever, not the only one. Depending on where you are and what you push on, the following are often negotiable.

  • The sum itself, especially where the consultation process was thin or rushed.
  • The structure and timing of payment, which can matter for tax across a year boundary.
  • The wording of your reference, ideally an agreed reference attached to the agreement so nobody can freestyle later.
  • Your restrictive covenants, which you can often get narrowed or released.
  • Outplacement support.
  • The treatment of your notice period and any pay in lieu.
  • What happens to unvested equity.
  • The wording of the internal and external announcement.
  • And a contribution to your legal fees.

You will not get all of it. You will get more than you would by signing the first offer you get.

The mindset that will get results

This is a negotiation, not a sentencing. The people who do best are not the loudest or the angriest. They're calm, specific, and unembarrassed. They say thank you, then they ask for things, in writing, with a reason attached to each one.

They also understand their leverage.

In a lot of European systems, a botched consultation or a shaky selection is genuinely expensive for the employer, which is exactly why a clean, quick settlement is attractive to them.

You don't have to threaten anything. You just have to know the cost of the alternative, and let that knowledge sit calmly in the room with you.

One thing to do this week

Before any offer arrives, write your list of asks. Not just the number. The reference, the covenants, the timing, the support. Rank them. Decide which two or three actually matter to you.

Walking in with a list is the difference between negotiating and just nodding. And whatever you do, do not sign anything in the room. Take it away. Get advice. Then respond.

Try this prompt:

Act as an experienced, level-headed redundancy negotiation coach. Here are the terms I've been offered: [paste]. 

List everything that might be negotiable beyond the headline figure. Then draft a calm, professional message asking for improvements, with a short reason attached to each ask. 

Flag anything I should have a qualified lawyer review before I sign.

Member discussion